Co$ Lies regarding Lisa on IR
These are snippets from older articles where church representatives
claimed Lisa was NOT on the Introspection Rundown, as they now admit
was actually the case.
Mystery surrounds Scientologist's death 12/15/96
By CHERYL WALDRIP of The Tampa Tribune
People who attended the wake in Dallas say Scientologists told them
McPherson died of "spinal meningitis."
Tampa attorney Robert Johnson who represents Scientology said
church members initially suspected meningitis and only later learned
that was not the case.
"No one knew what had happened to her," Johnson said. He said
they now believe McPherson had a strep infection. Authorities have no
indication of that.
[snip]
[Brian] Anderson said she was taken to the Fort Harrison Hotel because
she asked to go there, and there was no indication McPherson was ill
until the day of her death.
"Lisa at first didn't want to see a doctor but we talked her
into seeing a doctor," Anderson said. "She knew Dr. Minkoff and he
is an expert in infectious diseases so that's why she was taken
there."
[snip]
Police say they cannot confirm or deny the "baby watch" allegations.
Anderson said there is no such thing as "baby watch," and that
McPherson was never held in such a fashion.
"That's completely false and there is liability if you print
that," Anderson said. "It's not true."
* * * *
Cause of death in dispute
By JANE MEINHARDT and THOMAS C. TOBIN
"She didn't have a medical condition at all at that time," said Elliot
Abelson, a Los Angeles attorney representing the church. He said
McPherson checked into the hotel "to rest and think and get her
strength back."
He said he did not know what triggered McPherson's odd behavior. He
said she was free to come and go at the hotel. According to Abelson,
she received no medication or professional medical care while there.
Abelson said that near the end of her stay at the Fort Harrison,
McPherson's skin took on a yellow tint. She was seen by someone from
the church's Medical Liaison Office, which refers church staffers to
health professionals. "It didn't seem to be an emergency situation,"
he said.
* * * * *
3/30/97 --
Scientologists promised to care for woman who later died
Abelson said the church "watched her carefully" and that she was not
ill until the day she died on Dec. 5, 1995.
* * * *
Matt: Abelson also challenges the competency of the ME's office, and
said it conspired with the police when it issued this autopsy.
Abelson: They have absolutely no basis to say that she that didn't die
of natural causes.
Matt Hall: How do you know that?
Abelson: Because I've read the autopsy report
[snip]
Abelson: She rested, she slept a lot, uhh, nothing unusual, uhh,
really, until the end of her stay. She did (pause) get food, uhh,
water, obviously people talked to her. uhh, But she got rest and
relaxation.
Matt Hall: But later in our interview, Mr. Abelson does refer to
something unusual:
Abelson: But it was something very unusual to see this charming 36
year old woman hitting the wall.
Matt: With her body?
Abelson: No, with her fist
[snip]
Matt: While Scietnologists don't believe in psychiatric care, they do
have their own methods for dealing with members who are having what
they call "Psychotic Breaks" (the red volumes, quote from I rundown)
Their teaching call for isolating members who they believe are a
danger to themselves or others.
There was no construction to isolate Lisa, was there?
Abelson: No. Absolutely not. That was Lisa's wish.
Matt: And she was free to come and go?
Abelson: She was free to come and go.
Matt: Abelson says Lisa became physically ill very suddenly, and it
wasn't until the last 24 hours of her life that the people around her
had reason to be alarmed.
Abelson: She lost a lot of fluids at that time. There certainly wasn't
enough of a weight loss for anyone to suggest she be taken to the
hospital, earlier than the last 24 hours.
[snip]
Matt: You have a woman who's dehydrated, she's got severe diarrhea,
she's had excessive weight loss, and she's going in and out of
consciousness.
Abelson: She's sleepy. You know, rou're making more about this going
in and out of consciousness. She's tired.
Matt: Abelson says on the day Lisa died she participated in the
discussion about going to the hospital 25 miles away. They she'd even
walked, with help, part way to the van.
* * * *
Dispute over Scientologist's death
By THOMAS C. TOBIN
St. Petersburg Times, published January 23, 1997
The lab results "are consistent with a chronic process and are
consistent with an event such as a bloodstream infection that occurred
within a period of hours," Wood said. "She wasn't fine one day and
dead the next."
Wood also concluded that McPherson had been bitten by ants or roaches.
Her disclosures to the Times and to the television news magazine
Inside Edition infuriated Elliot J. Abelson, a Los Angeles lawyer who
represents Scientology. The church has its spiritual headquarters in
Clearwater.
In a phone interview Wednesday from Los Angeles, Abelson said of Wood:
"Liar. Liar. Liar. Liar. Liar. Hateful liar. That's what she is."
* * * *
Family sues Scientology in '95 death of woman
By THOMAS C. TOBIN
St. Petersburg Times, published February 20, 1997
The lawsuit filed Wednesday alleges that McPherson was in a coma and
was systematically subjected to a "series of
techniques," including a Scientology treatment known as the
"Introspection Rundown."
The treatment calls for isolation, against a person's will if
necessary, and mandates that those watching the person stay silent
during the treatment.
Abelson insisted McPherson did not receive the treatment.
He acknowledged that "it's part of church services" and added: "I'm
not making any excuses for it."
* * * *
St. Petersburg Times
According to Abelson, McPherson did not receive an Introspection
Rundown during her period of isolation.
[snip]
Abelson insisted McPherson did not receive the Introspection Rundown
or any other church services. Nevertheless, the
treatment is getting big play on the Internet, where Scientology
critics were among the first to suggest its possible implications in
the McPherson case.
The Introspection Rundown also is advertised on the church's Internet
site as one of several Scientology procedures for which church
counselors can get training.
Return to The Skeptic Tank's main Index page.
cultxpt@primenet.com (Jeff Jacobsen)
Sat, 15 May 1999 17:41:26 GMT
St. Petersburg Times, published December 17, 1996
By CHERYL WALDRIP of The Tampa Tribune
February 21, 1997
SCIENTOLOGY HAD WOMAN IN ISOLATION
By Thomas C. Tobin
The views and opinions stated within this web page are those of the
author or authors which wrote them and may not reflect the views and
opinions of the ISP or account user which hosts the web page. The
opinions may or may not be those of the Chairman of The Skeptic Tank.