The belief in "recovered memories" which have been suppressed
due to some unspeakable trama is on the decline here in the United States
-- at least among believers in a so-called "World-Wide Satanic
Cult." Believers in alien abductions which have been subjected to
false memory implantation by flying saucer nuts continues pretty much as
it has for the past 15 years or so, however.
Part of the reason why Satanic Rital Abuse claims are on the decline is
because such implanting of false memories adversely impacts innocent
people's lives. When a flying saucer believer implants alien abduction
"memories" into people, usually the only one harmed is the
individual who is told to believe it actually happened to them; their
families my shake their heads and wonder at their loved-one's sanity yet
at least people who are convinced they were abducted by aliens aren't
then demanding that their family members are in cahoots with the aliens.
Another big part of why False Memory Syndrome is on the decline is the
solid support that the academic communition has shown in debunking the
mistaken beliefs that memories such as what is claimed can be suppressed.
Finally, we see more and more victims of False Memory Syndrome taking
their therapists -- and the Christian churches which advocate and condone
such abuse -- to court and winning big settlements in conpensation for
their destroyed lives. - flr
False Memory Suit settled
By ALEXANDRA ZAVIS
CHICAGO (AP) - A woman has reached a $10.6 million settlement with a
hospital and two psychiatrists over accusations she was brainwashed into
believing she was a satanic high priestess.
The settlement casts more doubt on techniques popularized during the 1980s
as a way of helping patients recall traumatic experiences that doctors
believed they had blocked out from memory, her lawyer, Todd Smith, said
Tuesday.
Rush Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center agreed Monday to pay Patricia
Burgus $3.5 million, Smith said. The remainder will be paid by the
therapists.
Mrs. Burgus, 41, accused the hospital of using drugs and hypnosis to
convince her during a psychiatric ward stay from 1986-88 that she was a
member of satanic cult. She was persuaded that she had participated in
ritual murder, sexually abused her two children and had herself been
tortured - none of which was true - according to her lawsuit.
Burgus also said doctors persuaded her to hospitalize her two healthy
children, then age 4 and 5, for close to three years.
Lawyers for the hospital refused to comment on the settlement, which comes
after six years of litigation and involves no admittance of wrongdoing.
One therapist, Elva Poznanski, the hospital's section chief of child and
adolescent psychiatry, told The New York Times that the treatment for the
boys was correct given the information available.
The other doctor, Bennett Braun, director of the hospital's section of
psychiatric trauma, said the settlement was a ``travesty'' done over his
objection.
``A patient comes into the hospital doing so bad that she belongs in the
hospital and after several serious events in the hospital which I can't
disclose because of patient confidentiality, she was discharged and is
doing much better. Where's the damage?'' he told the Times.
The cult stories were raised by Burgus, said Braun, founding member of
the International Society for the Study of Dissociation, which deals with
multiple personality disorders. ``She just spit it out.'' He also said she
exaggerated the use of hypnotism in the treatment.
Burgus first sought treatment for depression after the difficult birth of
her second son in 1982, according to her lawsuit. She saw a number of
therapists in her hometown of Des Moines, Iowa, before being referred to
the Chicago hospital, where she said she was incorrectly diagnosed with
multiple personality disorder.
Her sons, now 15 and 17, were brought to hospital because doctors feared
they might also develop multiple personality disorder. They received a
variety of treatments, and were given a gun on one occasion to see if
they knew how to handle it, according to court documents.
``You cannot believe that this could happen in this country,'' Burgus
said. ``This is not the neighborhood shrink shack. It's a well-respected
institution. You expect cutting-edge treatment.''
She was transferred and then discharged from hospital, and started
questioning her treatment only after reading a critical magazine article
on recovered memory therapy, her lawsuit said.
The technique gained acceptance in the 1980s and was used in lawsuits and
criminal cases. A Redwood, Calif., man was sentenced to life in prison in
January 1990 for a 1969 slaying based on the recovered memory of his adult
daughter who witnessed the crime. But the case was later thrown out on
appeal.
In recent years, dozens of former mental patients have brought cases
alleging that false recollections were implanted in their memories by
their therapists, Smith said.
A church in Missouri agreed in 1996 to pay $1 million to a woman who said
a church counselor persuaded her to believe she had an abortion after her
being raped by her father - when in fact she was a virgin. That same year,
a judge reversed a $750,000 jury award to a women who claimed she had
recovered memories of being sexually abused 33 years earlier.
A study presented earlier this year at the American Association for the
Advancement of Science said that given a few bogus details and a little
prodding, about a quarter of adults can be convinced they remember
childhood adventures that never happened.
Return to The Skeptic Tank's main Index page.
The views and opinions stated within this web page are those of the
author or authors which wrote them and may not reflect the views and
opinions of the ISP or account user which hosts the web page.